From the video description
For argument based on knowledge implies instruction, and there are people whom one cannot instruct - Aristotle
Thursday, 20 June 2024
The Old Man at the Bridge
Labels:
Hemingway
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
For argument based on knowledge implies instruction, and there are people whom one cannot instruct - Aristotle
6 comments:
I've only tried one novel by Hemingway, and didn't get on with it. But that piece gives me a sense of why he is revered in some quarters.
Sam - I never got on with Hemingway either. I remember reading The Old Man and the Sea, but found his spare style too distant and uninvolved, like looking at things through the wrong end of a telescope.
I tried a couple of Hemingways as a boy. Didn't like his stuff and, in particular, decided he was a fraud - his pose of manliness was phoney.
P.S. "as the Fascists were set to overrun the region": Franco's army wasn't "the Fascists". It was a coalition, one part of which - the Falange - was fascist. There were also nationalists, royalists, and old-fashioned Roman Catholic reactionaries. There may even have been some liberals who disapproved of their nasty marxist/socialist/communist government.
But maybe the writer meant "Fascist" in the Guardian sense i.e. anyone he disapproves of.
dearieme - I don't know much about him but I've heard that his manliness pose was phoney. I'm sure he did mean "Fascist" in a lazy, Guardian sense.
It seems that a quote from 'an old man' will engender respect, sympathy etc., but that's not going to be much help if they're wrong when they talk to a younger man.
Scrobs - maybe that's Joe Biden's trick, wander off when you are wrong.
Post a Comment