Pages

Monday, 1 May 2023

Idiot Chic



David Mikics has a fine Tablet piece on communist chic in US schools.


Commie Chic Invades American Grade Schools

Angela Davis was a dedicated fangirl of Soviet dictator Leonid Brezhnev and cult leader Jim Jones. So why is she presented to children as a hero?

Every day, my son, who is in seventh grade, sees a quotation from Angela Davis painted on his school’s wall: “Radical simply means grasping things at the root.” (The line actually comes from Karl Marx.) Four years ago, during Black History Month, a poster of Davis beamed down from the wall of his public elementary school in Brooklyn.

I eagerly praise my son’s charter school to other parents. It’s full of dedicated teachers who urge their students to debate politics and history with an open mind. So I wrote to the administration, proposing that they should balance the school’s homage to Davis with a quotation from Andrei Sakharov or Natan Sharansky, who fought to free the millions of Soviet bloc citizens that Davis wanted to keep locked up. After all, I reasoned, some of the school’s families are themselves refugees from communist tyrannies. My suggestion was met with silence.



The whole piece is well worth reading because the horrors of the past are so easily and conveniently forgotten by modern fans of totalitarian rule.


The state of Virginia also officially discourages teaching about the criminal behavior of communist regimes. In February the Virginia Senate’s Democrats killed a Republican-sponsored bill that would have required public schools to teach students about the victims of communism. Public school teachers in Virginia are already required to cover slavery and the Holocaust. So why not communism? Because, a representative of the Virginia teachers union explained, “There is a strong association between communism and Asians,” and so studying communism could lead to anti-Asian hate.

Idiots will attack anyone for any reason—a fact to live with. But the Virginia teachers union explanation is plainly bunk. It seems exceedingly unlikely that high school students, after learning about the many millions of Chinese peasants sacrificed at Mao’s whim, would pin the blame for the dictator’s atrocities on the Chinese American kid sitting next to them in class—perhaps a descendent of one of Mao’s victims.

2 comments:

Sam Vega said...

That's excellent political writing. I loved this line:

"We are propelled by cowardice, convenience, and low ambition, attributes more fitting to an authoritarian nation than a free and democratic one."

If you haven't read it, Martin Amis's Koba the Dread approaches the same problem from a UK perspective: fellow-travellers like Christopher Hitchens and Ralph Miliband turning a blind eye to the appalling brutality of the Soviet Union, simply not addressing the issue of the millions dead and displaced.

A K Haart said...

Sam - thanks, I'll make a note of Koba the Dread. I have a note somewhere about an investigation into the 1929 Labour coalition government buying large quantities of Soviet timber, knowing it was produced by forced labour under appalling conditions where many died. Conveniently forgotten now.