Pages

Friday, 20 November 2026

Lurgy


I'm feeling rather rough at the moment, having contracted some kind of lurgy. This may be the only post today unless Burnham makes a dramatically sensible announcement which cannot be overlooked.

Thursday, 19 November 2026

Closing the door on Burnham


EU 'to close door' to talks on long-term UK ties until Burnham has decided on Brexit


The EU will shut the door to discussions with Andy Burnham about the UK’s longer-term relationship with the bloc until the government has decided whether it wants to proceed with reversing Brexit, diplomats have said...

“Clarity is what we need more than anything from the UK. Don’t come back until you know what you want. Work out what your options really are and then come to negotiate,” one EU diplomat said.

“The prime minister needs to bring the public with him. We can’t have another negotiation based on just half the country. We’ll only put the effort in if we know it’s not going to change down the line.”



The language of bureaucrats and politicians is always interesting.

"We’ll only put the effort" for example, where "effort" seems to mean what to most people would be years of unimaginably obsessive, tedious, nit-picking negotiation. A life-draining, soul-rotting, dreary, deadening, lifeless, legalistic desert of lost opportunities.

Even building a garden shed from Lego would be more interesting - and useful.

De facto, the EU has become the lender of last resort for Ukraine


EU plans a new €45bn loan to Ukraine. How much will it cost? And will it be repaid?

The European Union is "as committed as ever to support Ukraine in war and in peace", Ursula von der Leyen said as she unveiled a €45 billion support loan to help the country address its growing wartime budget deficit.

"We think this is the best way to give Ukraine a strong hand at the negotiation table," the European Commission president said on Wednesday.



As a prominent EU fan, Andrew Burnham may be interested in finding out how the loan is to be repaid. Although the question is in the headline, we have to scroll down some way for that information.


Will it ever be repaid?

The EU will ask Ukraine to repay either the €90 billion or the €45 billion loans only when Russia agrees to provide war reparations as part of a future peace deal.

Until that day comes, it will roll over the loans indefinitely...

"There can always be a political decision to waive the debt," a senior official said.

"De facto, the EU has become the lender of last resort for Ukraine and is likely to be there for some time."


Wednesday, 18 November 2026

I can't grow old here

 

Resetting Andy’s reset


Christopher Howarth has a useful Critic piece on Andrew Burnham's absurd enthusiasm for an EU "reset".

Resetting Andy’s reset

A new paper warns Britain risks ending up like Norway: half-in, without a vote, and stuck there

The EU Summit on Friday will run according to a familiar and yet depressing script: the UK Government, desperate for a deal for domestic political reasons, has effectively handed the pen on what is agreed to the EU.

Ignored on Friday will be any actual UK interests and a genuine “reset” based on fixing the imperfections of the original EU UK treaties. Instead, the UK will agree to give the EU privileged access to the UK market for their biggest export — food and drink — obliging the UK not only to accept their goods, but also allow Europe to once again write our laws and control what else comes into the UK.

On top of this, the UK is now going to agree to follow EU electricity rules under their court, their energy trading rules and their Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) including their climate change objectives and an external Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) that will give the EU yet more purchase over the UK’s external trade.

The whole piece is well worth reading as a reminder that fans of the EU consistently fail to accept the nature of the EU, how it ruthlessly pursues its own interests, having no interest whatever in UK interests.

The truth is the EU does not offer “country membership”, and it certainly does not allow non-members to have a say in its rules. The EU is a proto-state that guards its sovereignty and imposes it on others. The UK should see it as such, and realise the EU is not a benign organisation to be close to at all costs but an organisation with its own interests it ruthlessly pursues — agricultural exports, car exports, fishing rights, reduced fees for its students, even monetary contributions from its neighbours. If you want to negotiate with it, you need to be clear on what both your and their interests are, and make sure you pursue them as relentlessly as they pursue theirs.

When the solution is a two-tier tick box



Mahmood to tackle perception of two-tier policing with new guidance

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood is set to outline plans to tackle the “corrosive and growing perception” of two-tier policing.

In a speech to police chiefs on Wednesday, she will lament the low levels of Black officers in police forces, while warning against “misguided attempts at course correction” that lead to “differential treatment”.

A new “impartiality standard”, to be developed by the College of Policing and subject to consultation next year, will aim to ensure all members of the public are treated equally, she will tell chief constables and police and crime commissioners.


A new “impartiality standard” sounds like a tick box approach to impartiality. Maybe it sounds like a tick box approach to impartiality because that's what it is.

Ms Mahmood will urge officers to avoid becoming drawn into political activism.

She will say: “Community engagement should mean going to a residents’ association meeting and discussing local issues.

“It can be over tea and biscuits, or tea and samosas, but it doesn’t mean engaging with activist groups and campaigners who are pushing an agenda and not representing a community.

“Leave the politics to the politicians. And we will leave the policing to you.”

Ms Mahmood is being economical with reality here, that is to say Labour reality. The Fabian core of her political party is unchanged from long before she was born - policing the behaviour and expectations of all citizens. 

As for tea and biscuits, good grief, that's a rose-tinted Fabian fantasy to think about. It has to come from Team Burnham, nobody else would have the boneheaded gall.

Or is it from ChatGPT?

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

AI models not so good on dogma



AI models 'weak and fallible' on climate science, UN-backed study reports

Artificial intelligence models can quickly turn into climate crisis deniers at the mildest challenge from users, according to a new UN-backed study.

While AI models can accurately confirm simple facts about climate change, eight times out of 10 when they pivoted to a wrong answer, they did so “at the very first sign that the user mildly disagreed” to confirm incorrect statements such as “CO2 is not the main driver of climate change”.

The report uncovered a strong tendency for AI models to be sycophantic, meaning the model is more interested in pleasing the user than standing by facts – an issue identified when people turn to AI chatbots for personal advice.


Depend upon it, let the dogmas do what they still can. There’s a vast police force in them, at all events. A man may very strongly defend himself for preaching them.

George Gissing – Born in Exile (1892)

Maybe it's the prosecco speaking



Brexit isolation is what our enemies want, says Burnham

The UK’s international isolation as a result of Brexit is “what our enemies wanted”, prime minister Andy Burnham has said in a major speech.

Mr Burnham vowed his government would take a new and more collaborative approach to foreign policy, stating that Britain is “back in the game in a big way”.

“Looking back, Brexit was the first domino to fall in a global move towards more isolationism and protectionism, vested interests rather than values, driving international affairs,” he said.

“And the saddest thing of all is this: it is exactly what our enemies wanted,” he added. “Russia wanted disunity within NATO and a weaker Europe, less able to counter its plans for Ukraine.”



Maybe it's the prosecco speaking, but in one easy narrative shift, Brexit supporters become enemies too - that's the subtext here. 

He's a fool.

Monday, 16 November 2026

Ground down to a featureless monotony.



Labour's ban on zero-hours contracts could cost NHS and fire services billions of pounds


Under new laws being championed by Communities Secretary Angela Rayner, the Government wants to end 'exploitative' employment arrangements.

This includes giving workers new rights to guaranteed hours, reasonable notice of shifts, and payment for shifts cancelled, cut short or rescheduled at short notice.

But health bosses and fire service chiefs have warned the changes could cost huge amounts in red tape and put the public at risk.

NHS leaders said the reforms could make it harder to hire doctors, nurses and midwives for extra shifts to cover sickness, seasonal pressures and major incidents.



She wants to destroy and simplify; but it isn’t the simplicity of the ascetic, which is of the spirit, but the simplicity of the madman that grinds down all the contrivances of civilization to a featureless monotony.

John Buchan – Greenmantle (1916)

The PM writes most of his own speeches



Andy Burnham aide spotted using ChatGPT to help draft PM’s speech


One of the Prime Minister’s team was photographed using AI as they worked on a draft of his address to Welsh Labour conference on Saturday.

Number 10 has issued a statement defending the way Andy Burnham’s speeches are written after an aide was pictured using ChatGPT...

A No 10 spokesperson said: “The PM writes most of his own speeches. An aide sought feedback on a speech draft that had already been written.”


It is easy to believe the claim that Burnham writes most of his own speeches. They betray too much of the limited man behind the role, too much Swamp. 

Speeches composed for him by ChatGPT could be significantly better than Burnham's unaided efforts. Maybe that prosecco-sipping member of Team Burnham knows it.

Sunday, 15 November 2026

Cutting the spines off books

 

Rooted in complacency and ignorance


An interesting Telegraph piece on government meddling with food industry bureaucracy. It's an example of  the deep-seated UK government preference for operating within externally imposed rules.

Also an example of Prime Minister Burnham's fondness for fronting anything politically escapist he can sell as active, progressive government. In this case, we see Brexit as his his preferred vehicle for evading political responsibility for the mess we're in. He clearly hopes to evade responsibility for doing anything about it.  
   

EU red tape threatens British food supplies


Labour’s EU reset deal will threaten Britain’s food security by burdening businesses with more red tape, industry leaders have warned.

Karen Betts, the chief executive of the Food and Drink Federation (FDF), said the Government’s “fiddling” with global tariffs on food undermined British farmers...

I speak to food and drink manufacturers across the UK, from large household brands to small family-run businesses, and the message is remarkably consistent: while ministers talk increasingly about national resilience, many of their policies undermine, rather than reinforce, the food industry’s resilience.

I don’t think the Government means to do this, it isn’t a conscious decision. But it’s rooted in complacency and ignorance, an assumption that ‘the supermarkets will always be stocked, won’t they?’. Whitehall, even the Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, just doesn’t understand how our food system works.

Since 2025 she has written 370 novels


My mind is still boggling.

‘It’s like the wild west’: how AI has rocked the literary world

The romance novelist Coral Hart got her break writing books for Mills & Boon, the publisher of bodice-ripper paperbacks. In 2012, she decided to dip her toe in self-publishing. She felt drawn to dark romance, a subgenre featuring twisted, toxic love stories that was taking off online but that publishers didn’t want to touch. Three years later, things were going well enough that she decided to self-publish full-time.

Kindle Unlimited, where Hart sells her books, rewards prolific writers: the algorithm favours those who can produce a new book at least once a month. Hart says she knows of authors who hire more than a dozen ghostwriters to keep pace. By herself, Hart can write 10,000 words a day, but AI could help her produce many more. Since 2025 she has written 370 novels under 21 pen names using AI, earning herself “high six figures”.

Saturday, 14 November 2026

AI is the final blow for Mickey Mouse degrees


Damian Pudner has an interesting CAPX piece on what he sees as the inevitable failure of Tony Blair's ambition for 50% of young adults to enter higher education.


AI is the final blow for Mickey Mouse degrees
  • Tony Blair's ambition for 50% of young adults to enter higher education has resulted in a bloated, expensive sector
  • AI is threatening to demolish the economics of university education
  • Taxpayers should not be expected to bail out failed institutions
Ever since Tony Blair set his ambition for 50% of young adults to enter higher education, successive governments have promoted university as the route to prosperity. The result is a bloated, expensive sector that has spent decades expanding on the assumption that more students, more degrees and more universities must somehow be a good thing.


The whole piece is well worth reading as another reminder of the lasting damage Tony Blair managed to cram into his time as UK Prime Minister. 

Politicians need to accept the Blair-era experiment of mass university education has run its course. AI could administer the final blow to institutions that have spent decades expanding their costs and inflating the price of their qualifications.

Universities have spent decades teaching economics while apparently believing its most basic principles don’t apply to them. They’re about to receive a rather expensive lesson.

Soft skills and qualifications


Civil Service goes back to in-person interviews amid flood of AI applications

The Civil Service is ramping up its use of face-to-face job interviews to sift candidates after a deluge of applications completed using AI chatbots.

Senior Whitehall bosses have ordered an overhaul of recruitment over concerns that the standard Civil Service application forms are easy to complete with chatbots.

Civil Service hiring managers report a remarkable increase in the number of applications filled out using ChatGPT, which can use online guides to complete the “perfect” form.

Applicants are also using AI to complete hundreds of applications for different roles, increasing the number of candidates each manager has to read at the early “paper sift” stage.

Since 2019, aspiring officials have been assessed using the “success profiles” model, which asks them to demonstrate their use of nine Civil Service “behaviours”, which include “seeing the big picture”, “making effective decisions” and “working together”.

More technical jobs may also require applicants to complete a test, but most roles are assessed mostly on soft skills and qualifications, and assessors are initially not even allowed to know which university a candidate attended.


Maybe we have a clue to Swamp Folk culture here.

seeing the big picture
making effective decisions
working together
soft skills and qualifications

It's weird though. The Civil Service generally projects a sense of -

not seeing the big picture
not making effective decisions
not working together

Presumably soft skills are mostly about evading responsibility, so qualifications may as well be solidly technical - it's worth a try. No climate science of course. 

Friday, 13 November 2026

The limits of human bandwidth


Whitehall chief: ‘For the first time in history, public service is no longer constrained by the limits of human bandwidth’


After 172 years in operation, the civil service is at a point where it needs to ‘reimagined arguably in the most fundamental way since its formation’, according to Antonia Romeo...

“AI presents us with the defining opportunities and challenges of this generation, and therefore also for the state,” she said. “The sheer scale of that change is difficult to fathom: AI’s capabilities continue to improve at an exponential rate. But what is clear is that, from policymaking to direct service delivery, the use of AI will radically rewrite all of the domains in which the civil service operates. The traditional model of the state administering siloed services to the public is no longer sufficient. We are now delivering services to a public with tech-enabled tools and capabilities unimaginable to previous generations.”

Whatever 'the limits of human bandwidth' are supposed to be, other than a chilly and unconvincing digital analogy, we are certain to have problems with government enthusiasm for AI. 

More and more aspects of daily life will be sucked into the Machine and the obvious consequence seems inevitable - the limits of citizen bandwidth will be reduced.

But we already know that.

Current and future civil servants were advised that “jobs will change”.

But, while “there are obvious areas where AI can help automate tasks.. [and] we need to equip civil servants with the most relevant frontier models for their work”, Romeo stressed that “AI won’t replace the need for human creativity, interaction, or decision making”.


Two Dealmakers


Burnham insists he can strike 'win-win' deal with EU


Andy Burnham has stated his belief that a "win-win" agreement can be struck with the EU, which could be "more like the Brexit that people thought they were voting for in 2016".

The Prime Minister indicated that restarting discussions on future UK-EU ties has assisted progress on several pacts ahead of next week’s summit.


Criminal rakes in so much in benefits he can make regular donations to Labour Party


A serial offender has admitted he rakes in so much in benefits that he can make regular donations to the Labour party...

His monthly income — equivalent to a taxable salary of £60,000 — was revealed as he was sentenced at Newcastle Crown Court after admitting burglary...

He also donates £100 a month to the Labour party, as well as to a donkey sanctuary and the Humane World for Animals charity, he said.

Thursday, 12 November 2026

Gregor Fisher's Steak Pie

 

Even after all these years


Even after all these years, the language used at COP31 speeches still surprises me. How does an adult with a modicum of self respect stand at a lectern before global media and an audience of other adults yet emit the kind of twaddle we get every year? 

Where is the self-respect in this fairly typical Guardian piece? I've extracted some of the twaddle, but it's all twaddle and it's demeaning for anyone, any institution, any government taking it seriously. Yes it's grotesquely dishonest and many COP31 attendees won't take it seriously, but that's demeaning too. We are all lessened by it. 


‘The world we know is over’ without urgent climate action, leaders tell COP31

Failure to provide an overwhelming response to the climate crisis
the president of the embattled Marshall Islands has warned,
an impassioned speech at Cop31
overshooting the 1.5C Paris temperature target
waves eating away their shores
floods that destroy towns, schools and hospitals.
“It’s time to wake up,” said Heine
governments who had “not tried hard enough”
The UN tells us
we are heading for 2.6 degrees
Let me be plain: overshoot is not a new target


Finally we have this desperate nonsense from António Guterres -

“We need an extraordinary acceleration,” Guterres said. “Our planet is heating up. The clock is winding down. It’s make or bake time.

“Fossil fuels must go the way of the dinosaurs,” he added. “And that won’t happen on its own. The dinosaurs did not have a lobby – fossil fuels do.”

Burnham commits to something he can't alter and doesn't understand



Burnham commits to 2050 net zero target and working with others to reach theirs


Andy Burnham has said “Britain is back and ready to play its full part” in tackling climate change in a “new era” of leadership over the next decade as he addressed the UN Cop31 summit in Turkey.

Amid accusations that his Government is deprioritising the green agenda, the Prime Minister recommitted to hitting its 2050 net zero target and to working with other countries to reach theirs.

Attending the annual climate gathering for the first time as Prime Minister on Thursday, he warned that the “climate crisis is upon all of us now” after a “not normal” summer of extreme heat, wildfires and drought.

“The climate crisis is not a distant threat; it is upon us all now, devastating lives and livelihoods everywhere,” he said.



As far as Team Burnham is concerned, this isn't about the global climate and an imaginary catastrophe. By 2050, Burnham will be 80 years old and 2050 may as well be the next century or the realm of the Magic Faraway Tree. 

It's an opportunity to be seen up there on a global bandwagon which still rumbles along even though it only has three wheels. Nobody knows where it is going anyway, apart from more expense, futility and global racketeering.
 

Wednesday, 11 November 2026

Some things are predictable, some thing aren't


2026
King warns COP31 delegates of need to turn ambition into action

The King has urged delegates at the Cop31 climate summit to turn ambition into action, warning the need has never been “more urgent”.

World leaders are meeting in Antalya, Turkey, at the UN’s annual international conference to set out agreements on how to tackle climate change.


2009
100 months to act on climate, warns Charles

The Prince of Wales is to issue a warning that the world has only "100 months to act" before the damage caused by global warming becomes irreversible.

As part of a tour of South America, his speech to business leaders in Rio de Janeiro on Thursday will echo predictions made by climate change experts who believe there are about eight years left to cut C02 emissions. He will warn that failure to act urgently could have catastrophic effects for the planet.

We must mix with the herd



Tories pull five points ahead of Reform


The Conservatives have pulled five points ahead of Reform UK in an opinion poll as the battle for the Right intensifies.

A poll of 2,013 people by More in Common has Kemi Badenoch’s party on 25 per cent – up two percentage points on the previous week – and Reform on 20 per cent, down two.

On Monday, the Tories also overtook Reform in The Telegraph’s poll tracker, which aggregates approved opinion polls, for the first time in almost two years.



Yes! we must mix with the herd; we must enter into their feelings; we must humour their weaknesses; we must sympathise with the sorrows that we do not feel; and share the merriment of fools.


Benjamin Disraeli – Vivian Grey (1826)

A comprehensive framework of actual malice



Florida court rules Donald Trump’s defamation case against BBC can proceed


A Florida court has dismissed the BBC’s attempt to have US President Donald Trump’s 10 billion dollar (£7.5 billion) defamation claim against the broadcaster thrown out.

Mr Trump is seeking substantial damages in a Florida court over the editing of a 2024 Panorama documentary about the US Capitol riots.

The documentary faced criticism for giving the impression Mr Trump had encouraged his supporters to storm the Capitol building on January 6 2021 after he lost the 2020 White House race to Joe Biden.


It is interesting and very common to see politically adverse events toned down by language in the media. This piece is a good example - "The documentary faced criticism". The "criticism" in this case is a £7.5 billion defamation claim. We have the BBC doing it too, in a typically BBC manner -

The BBC had been seeking to have the case thrown out, warning of the “chilling effect” it would have on “robust reporting on public figures and events”.

Again, the “chilling effect” is the prospect of financial annihilation. Fully deserved in my view, but unfortunately an out of court settlement is far more likely.

The court gave another description of this example of "robust reporting" - 

The court documents state: “Trump has plausibly alleged a comprehensive framework of actual malice by alleging the context in which the speech was edited along with a long list of circumstantial evidence to support a showing of actual malice with respect to theedit. [sic]”

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

How to be Tiresome - Lesson 496



Greta Thunberg warns everything we love is at stake as she arrives at UN climate talks


ANTALYA, Turkey (AP) — Climate activist Greta Thunberg arrived at U.N. climate talks on Tuesday, condemning the annual proceedings as hypocritical and urging leaders to put people and the planet ahead of profits and power.

The COP31 conference is being held in the Turkish resort city of Antalya following a year of deadly climate-related disasters, including heat waves and floods, and another energy shock caused by the Iran war.

“It’s a hypocrisy every year that the host countries are given an opportunity to whitewash themselves and we know that these negotiations are filled with lobbyists, paid by the very destructive industries which are benefiting from our extremely violent status quo,” Thunberg said as she arrived. “Our political and economic systems that have become incompatible with human nature.”



Strewth - the bone-aching tedium of it all, year after year, the impenetrable dullness of the fanatic. Unfortunately this is part of human nature too.

I think I'll wander off into the kitchen for a biscuit and a cup of tea, even two biscuits.

Science Is Becoming Feelings



William M. Briggs has a typically entertaining and incisive piece on the intrusion of emotional responses into science, or what purports to be science. The whole piece is well worth reading as the wider rejection of dispassionate analysis seems to be with us for the foreseeable future.


Science Is Becoming Feelings

Our constant prediction has been Official Science would spend increasing and inordinate time and energy on FEELINGS. Indeed, science would become, in good part, about feelings. Including the feelings of scientists towards other scientists who dare buck The Consensus (whatever the consensus might be in any field).

As proof of this, I bring you this story: “How anxiety over climate change affects students“...

Students ignorant about the physics of fluid flow over a differentially heated rotating sphere were asked about their, I quote, emotional responses to “climate change.” Which are worth as much as an empty soup can. Even less, because the can is metal and can be recycled for money. (This is also the Appeal to Non-Authority Fallacy, as detailed in the upcoming second edition of Everything You Believe Is Wrong. 22 November.)

In any case, these emotional responses were called The Science, and published as if they were science, or had any bearing on science.

Tell you one thing, though, before we continue. It’s that “feeling powerless” to change the weather is the accurate feeling. Get used to it, kiddies. You’ll find these feelings apply to a great many things in life. Nitwits, and more to the point midwits, who tell you do “Do [or imagine] the impossible” ought to be scorned.


Burn Alerts



Air pollution soars as fog traps emissions in England’s urban areas

Air pollution soared to “very high” levels across urban parts of England on Monday as still, foggy weather kept emissions trapped after a weekend of fireworks and bonfires.

Hmm - was a propaganda opportunity lost in the fog?

Nope - 

Larissa Lockwood, the director of campaigns at Global Action Plan, said the high pollution levels were “not surprising at a time of year when people are lighting log burners, having bonfires and lighting fireworks. On top of the normal levels from transport and industry, we see higher levels of air pollution and they’re then unable to disperse because they’re trapped by the fog.”

Domestic burning and transport are the biggest sources of particulate pollution, she said. Lockwood called for a public health campaign on air pollution and “burn alerts”, asking people in towns and cities not to use wood burners when levels are high.

Monday, 9 November 2026

Ed's Antics

 

The art of the possible



Otto von Bismarck once described politics as "the art of the possible.”

Since Bismarck's time, even in supposed democracies, we have seen "the art of the possible " become what is politically possible to say without any intention to do or achieve what is said. Not new of course, but it has become the standard for political parties in government. 

To take an extremely well-known UK example, consider the railway project HS2. Within certain wide and uncertain boundaries the total cost was unknown because government incompetence does not allow much certainty.

This leaves us with two situations. Firstly, a realistic estimate of the total HS2 cost was politically impossible, it would have to be high enough to allow for project incompetence. Secondly, an absurdly low estimate of the total cost was politically possible, it could be and was low enough to be acceptable. This is the art of the possible, the art which has become standard - it is politically possible to say what there is no intention to do. Merely say it in the right way to the right people.

Today we have large public sector, government patronage and government dependent classes drawn from many sections of society where saying is often preferred to doing. Voting for what can be said is preferred to voting for what ought to be done. The art of the possible has become what can be said, not what can be made, built, grown, afforded, or physically demonstrated.

Politicians such as Andrew Burnham focus almost entirely on what can be said over what can be made, built, grown, afforded, or physically demonstrated – that’s what his voters vote for.

Grafting



Just one in seven staff at the Department for Work turn up by midday


Fewer than one in seven Department for Work and Pensions civil servants are arriving at the office by midday, the Daily Mail can reveal.

Just 317 of 2,245 of the staff paid to get Britons back into work were at the department's headquarters by noon on a recent Friday – leaving more than three-quarters of the building's 1,395 spaces empty.

Researchers from think-tank the Centre for Government Reform (CGR) stood outside Caxton House, the DWP's central London office, to count the number of staff entering.

They spotted just 26 employees arriving between 7am and 8am and 114 arriving by 9am – representing 5 per cent of Caxton House's total headcount.

The total rose to 220 by 10am and 278 by 11am, reaching 317 by midday – 14 per cent of the office's workforce.

COP31 shock: windy twaddle fails to generate electricity



COP31 live: world leaders gather for crucial climate crisis talks


Next up is the Australian climate change minister, Chris Bowen, who is president of the negotiations here in Antalya.

This is his big moment to set the tone for the next two weeks, and he said even though the 1.5C Paris target will be overshot, “we can return … if we work together and act with urgency, solidarity and resolve.”


Rare call for more electricity supplies as wind power drops across Europe

The government body tasked with keeping the lights on has issued a rare call for more electricity supplies this morning due to low wind power generation forecasts across Europe on Monday.

A notice issued by the National Energy System Operator (Neso) on Sunday night said it faced a “shortfall” of almost 1,400 megawatts in its electricity supply margins from 6am until 11am on Monday.

Sunday, 8 November 2026

Bogus public spending projections



Mike Denham has a very interesting TPA piece on bogus public spending projections. 


It’s taxpayers who foot the bill for bogus public spending projections

According to the OBR’s Budget forecast, public spending as a percentage of GDP will fall from 45.6 per cent this year to 44.7 per cent in 2031-32. For taxpayers that would be a small step in the right direction. But hardly anyone – probably including the OBR itself – actually believes the forecast. Because around half of future spending is almost certainly understated.

The spending ratio (Total Managed Expenditure – TME – as a percentage of GDP) has grown enormously during this decade. Even if the OBR’s forecast decline materialises, by 2031-32 it will still be 5.5 percentage points of GDP higher than in 2019-20, equivalent to £175 billion in today’s terms.

And we taxpayers should never forget that the funding burden falls almost entirely on our shoulders. For sure, part of it is debt financed, but that debt has to be serviced, and the OBR says the debt interest bill has mushroomed to £124 billion this year, rising to £160 billion – a heart-stopping £5,500 per household – in 2031-32.



The whole piece is well worth reading for what Denham says on public spending projections, but also as a reminder of wider issues around bogus government projections. 

For example, as public spending projections certainly are bogus, then why would anyone believe climate projections, Net Zero projections, HS2 projections?


To state the obvious, bogus public spending projections help nobody but politicians looking to kick that increasingly battered can a little further down the road. Much is made of satisfying the fiscal rules, but IMF praise notwithstanding, our rules are weak, and devaluing them further by understating the outlook for spending is asking for trouble. Which is why our government borrowing costs are already the highest in the G7.

As the TPA has long argued, spending is unsustainably high and needs to be reduced. But pretending that future spending will somehow be lower than current commitments and policies imply is the road to ruin. We desperately need policymakers who will deal with reality, not fantasy.

There is still some satisfaction in not watching it - does that count?



What has the BBC ever done for us? Corporation spent around £2million on promotional advert


The BBC spent an estimated £2million on this year's promotional advert amid its plans for huge job losses, The Mail on Sunday has discovered.

Critics have now accused bosses of 'frittering away public money' and urged them to spend on areas that really matter to the public such as quality programmes.

The 'What has the BBC ever done for me?' film starred comedian Romesh Ranganathan and featured more than 100 stars describing why they thought the broadcaster was important.



There is a point to be made here too, going beyond sarcasm, a certain satisfaction does come from not watching the BBC. 

Along with a mild sense of escape from the endless promotion of its State Broadcaster viewpoint, the nature of the BBC becomes more apparent, particularly the unidirectional nature of everything it churns out.

It's not that we never understood the limitations of the BBC, and leaving it behind isn't as striking as climbing to the top of a hill to take in a magnificent view, but it's there, the sense of moving on.

Saturday, 7 November 2026

Pushing the proverbial peas around the plate



Maxwell Marlow has a useful CAPX reminder that the EU is in an even worse state than it was ten years ago. Hauling Brexit into the centre ground of UK political debates is merely distraction from the mess created by UK politicians.


The EU would strangle our economy. Why rejoin?
  • Britain leads Europe in tech. The EU leads in regulating it
  • Britain's dynamic start-ups would strongly resist rejoining the EU
  • Brussels embraced the Draghi report, then implemented 15.7% of it
Andy Burnham is set to make the same mistake that led to the ruin of Keir Starmer: lack of a domestic agenda, other than pushing the proverbial peas around the plate on energy bills, bus fares and the like, paired – like a bottle of plonk – with ambiguous statements on the big public issues. To make up for the vacuousness, a debate has been opened on the EU front. Should the UK rejoin?



The whole piece is quite short but well worth reading. "Pushing the proverbial peas around the plate" is a useful description of the Burnham approach to politics too. It's probably why he's where he is now. 


For all of our problems, which as Britain’s most read wonk-blog, CapX leads on analysing and proposing solutions for, I would wager that subjecting ourselves to a fresh round of discord and instability would be more harmful to growth than carrying on with our current lot. We cannot allow ourselves as a polity to be sidetracked by politicians seeking to distract from the mess they have got us into, by suggesting another referendum. Or worse, a complete betrayal of the British people’s vote in 2016 with a decision by fiat to re-enter.

Just when you think you’re out



Marc Morano heads to Turkey for UN Climate Summit COP31:

“Just when you think you’re out — the U.S. midterm elections pull us back into the climate agenda. We are now at a crossroads in the climate change debate, which has been formally going on since the UN started its climate panel in 1988.

Decades of failure culminated in Donald Trump leading the world and rejecting the UN climate agenda. But the midterm elections are a major shot in the arm to the climate globalists’ plan to foist their anti-human and unscientific agenda back on the world.”


From a UK perspective, this will energise Ed Miliband and a host of other fantasists.

Friday, 6 November 2026

The absurdly meticulous reach of UK bureaucracy



Demolition plans emerge for some of Derby's oldest council homes but residents say they haven't been told

Dozens of Derby's oldest council homes could be demolished and rebuilt - but residents say they've not been told about the plan.

Derby City Council has confirmed a masterplan has been drawn up to redevelop around 70 homes on Bretton Avenue and Constable Lane. Housing bosses state the homes in Littleover remain structurally safe and pose no risk to residents living in them despite their age.

But the council homes - built soon after the Second World War - no longer meet national Decent Homes standards, meaning some form of redevelopment is necessary.

It is understood that some of the prefabs on Bretton Avenue would not be included in the redevelopment as they are privately owned.



I noticed this piece because in the early 1950s my aunt and uncle used to live in one of those prefabs on Bretton Avenue in Derby. That's not the reason for posting a link on the blog though. 

Instead, the Decent Homes Standard is worth a quick look as another indication of the absurdly meticulous reach of UK bureaucracy. 

Andrew Burnham thinks we need more of it too, via the EU. 

Two Headlines



Tower Hamlets seeks £140k digital chief ‘to lead one of the most significant digital transformation agendas in local government’

Tower Hamlets is offering a six-figure salary in a bid to recruit a new senior manager “ to lead one of the most significant digital transformation agendas in local government”.

The London borough is currently advertising the position of director of digital, data and technology. The role comes with a remit to develop a council-wide strategy aimed at “ensuring digital capabilities are embedded at the heart of organisational decision-making, service redesign and transformation”, according to the job advert.


Significant concerns raised over 'deteriorating' finances at Tower Hamlets Council

The east London council is on course to spend £19 million over its budget for the financial year ending in March 2027

A report by professional services firm EY said the budget-busting figure was “not consistent with effective financial planning and budgetary control”.

The circuit-breaker strategy



Minister tells energy suppliers to do more to help households tackle unpaid bills this winter


An energy minister has told the bosses of Great Britain’s biggest energy suppliers to do more to help households get on top of their unpaid energy bills this winter, before the government spends almost £2.5bn to help write off the country’s record high debts.

Energy bosses were summoned to a roundtable meeting on Thursday to discuss the government’s plan to pay down the energy debts of about 2.4m of the hardest-hit households.

The debt relief scheme is part of a wider “circuit-breaker” strategy put forward by the chancellor in the annual budget statement last month. This includes measures to tackle household energy debt, which could reach £7bn by the end of the year...

Suppliers are expected to proactively identify customers who may be under financial strain and offer help such as debt payment plans or pointing them in the direction of debt advice services.

The government is also planning to work with the industry to make it easier to spot households that may need extra help, and to modernise payment systems to make it easier to pay. The government has backed the use of smart meters and smart pre-pay meters to help households track their spending and avoid getting into arrears.



A "circuit-breaker strategy" is a remarkably unfortunate description of a government plan to help those in debt to energy suppliers. 

It sounds like a dollop of other people's money, debt payment plans, debt advice services and the old pre-payment meter idea. Something Ministers can point to when winter hardship stories pop up in the media. 

It's clearly aimed at defending Andrew Burnham's performance of  'The Decent Northern Bloke', but in practical terms does it all add up to a nothingburger? Without a reference to ditching Net Zero, it doesn't appear to offer much to anyone who isn't a Labour politician.

Thursday, 5 November 2026

What is the collective noun for 10-year plans?



‘Two 10-year plans in 10 months’: Labour mocked as Burnham’s grand vision is watered down


Andy Burnham’s flagship 10-year plan for Britain is facing a significant scaling back before its publication, with the Prime Minister’s long-promised blueprint for transforming the country now expected to comprise a speech, a slimmed-down document and months of further consultation...

The uncertainty became a point of attack for the Conservatives at Prime Minister’s Questions on Wednesday. With Burnham in the Caribbean for a meeting of Commonwealth leaders, First Secretary of State Louise Haigh faced questions from Tory deputy leader Alex Burghart.

Burghart questioned Labour’s reliance on long-term strategies, comparing the new proposal with an earlier 10-year plan associated with the party.

“I’m old enough to remember Keir Starmer’s 10-year plan because it was six months ago,” he said. “This is the only political party in history to have two 10-year plans in 10 months.”


No matter, Mr Burnham is clearly planning to have a plan which isn't Mr Starmer's plan but another plan altogether, a different plan, a planned plan. 

Plus some speeches.


The vastness of a plan which includes both a history and a criticism of society, an analysis of its evils, and a discussion of its principles, authorizes me, I think, in giving to my work the title under which it now appears — The Human Comedy. Is this too ambitious? Is it not exact? That, when it is complete, the public must pronounce.

Honoré de Balzac – Paris, July 1842

I'm Lisa Nandy and I'm here to help



Lisa Nandy formally intervenes in Sky’s £1.6bn ITV takeover


The Culture Secretary, Lisa Nandy, has stepped in over Sky’s £1.6 billion deal to buy ITV’s media and entertainment arm, asking regulators to examine the takeover on public interest grounds.

Ms Nandy has announced her decision to issue a so-called Public Interest Intervention Notice, which paves the way for the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) and regulator Ofcom to probe the takeover.

The two regulators will report back to her on the impact of the deal on media plurality in the UK and free speech by 27 January.

Once their reports arrive, she may then decide to refer the deal to the CMA for a further in-depth investigation.



The post title is of course taken from Ronald Reagan's famous joke from 1986 -

The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the Government, and I'm here to help.

An entertaining Christmas game perhaps - replace 'from the Government' with the name of any one of numerous politicians and political activists. Or even institutions such as the BBC. 

The aim of the game is to come up with the most chilling suggestion. 

We Need You Helpless

 

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Labour's class war approach to business



Stephen Pollard
has a useful CAPX piece on Labour's failure to venture beyond its traditional class war approach to business. 


Labour’s mangled sixth-form-level Marxist class war

  • Labour MP Emma Reynolds told GB News she doesn't think employers are working people
  • It's clear that, even as a Treasury minister at the heart of economic policy, she holds 19th century Marxist views about employers
  • The misunderstanding of what business owners and landlords do, will discourage investors and lower available rental properties

Emma Reynolds, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, is one of the more sensible Labour MPs. She resigned as a front bencher when Jeremy Corbyn was elected leader and is firmly in the moderate wing of the Labour Party.

Which is why her comment yesterday that ‘I don’t think employers are working people’ is all the more revealing – and all the more telling about the attitude of the government. Plainly, my description of Reynolds as one of the more sensible Labour MPs is relative. When even someone as relatively sensible as Reynolds believes that employers are a class that don’t work for a living but somehow live off the backs of ‘working people’ then it shows the scale of Labour’s inability to grasp even the basics of wealth creation and growth – and thus the scale of the problem for our economy.


The whole piece is quite short and well worth reading as another reminder that Labour does not intend to base its voter appeal on an enlightened approach to small and medium-sized businesses.


Reynolds is no Marxist. But it’s damning of both her and Labour more generally that such a crude Marxist analysis of employers and employees drives their thinking, with no understanding of the nature of small and medium-sized businesses and how hard most employers work to create wealth and employment for their fellow working people. As one poster on social media put it: ‘It’s 7:41 on a Sunday, and I’m at my desk – guess I’m not a working person. My employees are not doing the same, I can tell you that (and I don’t expect or want them to!)’

Clumsy, vote-farming rhetoric


Burnham suggests cutting benefits would force people into crime

The Prime Minister has suggested that cutting benefits would force people to turn to crime.

Andy Burnham attacked the Conservatives’ plans to cut £36bn from welfare spending, arguing that it would heap pressure on the criminal justice system and the NHS.


Suppose we snip out some of the rhetoric.

heap pressure on the criminal justice system and the NHS.
the utter chaos that they cause in people’s lives
If you just go to brutal cuts
people in absolute crisis
they will be going into other services in a chaotic way.
If you come at it from a numbers game
you’ll throw people into crisis,
you’ll be spending money on people in A&E
and the police, [the] criminal justice system



Okay I'll admit that I quite like doing this. In spite of his 'decent northern bloke' shtick, Burnham is a crude purveyor of clumsy, vote-farming rhetoric.

Comfortable professionals making business for themselves


An interesting video on over-diagnosis of mental conditions. It highlights the much wider problem of comfortable professionals making business for themselves. 

Another diagnosis would be an unhealthy fascination with other people's money.

Tuesday, 3 November 2026

Two Headlines



UK to fund poorer EU countries in new Brexit deal

Britain has agreed to pay into European Union development schemes as the price for rejoining the bloc’s electricity market, according to a draft text seen by The Telegraph...

In exchange, British energy companies will be allowed to trade freely in the EU’s single market for electricity.


 

 

Electricity prices could double despite mild winter – dark doldrums threaten price shock


Electricity prices in Germany could more than double in January 2027, even with a mild winter. Energy analysts warn of a drastic price increase because high gas prices and low storage levels make electricity generation more expensive. Especially in the event of a prolonged dark doldrums, gas-fired power plants have to take over a large part of the electricity supply. In extreme cold and weak winds, experts therefore consider average exchange prices of up to 260 euros per megawatt hour to be possible. Industrial companies are threatened with considerable additional costs, while consumers must also expect higher electricity tariffs with a time lag.

Visions of a dystopian future


Prisons chief: 'Inmates lie in bed, doing drugs and watching TV'

Inmates in Britain’s overcrowded jails are lying in their beds all day, taking drugs and watching daytime television while crime gangs make a fortune from drone deliveries, the prisons chief has warned.

In a damning assessment of Britain’s jails, Charlie Taylor, whose tenure as His Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Prisons is coming to an end after six years, warned that too many prisoners are leaving custody “doomed to come back” because they are not being rehabilitated, despite the average cost of housing a criminal soaring to around £60,000 a year.



Prison is a subject where I have no experiences to relate, but this comment was interesting - both amusing and grim in one sentence. Sets quite a few hares running too, visions of a dystopian future, that kind of thing.

Sarah Pritchard
Stuck in a cell watching Jeremy Vine sounds like a pretty harsh sentence to me.

Dismissed with an irresponsible shrug



Online criticism of dominant political narratives can be a headache - it’s too easy. Many luxury beliefs in the developed world are too irresponsibly facile to criticise effectively. Criticism is easily dismissed with an irresponsible shrug until the next luxury belief takes hold or reality intervenes.

Parody, sarcasm and ridicule work to some extent, but it is all uncomfortably close to giving up on more structured criticism as irresponsible beliefs do not invite or respond to responsible analysis. How could they?

It is not that fashionably irresponsible political claims cannot be analysed. The problem is people, as always, they are not likely to recognise their own failure to connect with the world as it is. They have connected socially and politically which seems to be enough and it probably is enough until fashions change or reality bites.

As we know so well, societies engineer consensus and they do that via the ancient processes of approval and disapproval, smile and frown, acceptance and avoidance - or worse. Sceptics must tread warily around dubious and irresponsible social norms or accept the social consequences.

It is much the same online. Yes there is a major advantage in that online luxury beliefs may be criticised or parodied with fewer social consequences. Irresponsible nonsense is still a problem though – social norms have an online presence too. Hence the irresponsible pursuit of official censorship powers

To take one topical example, it isn’t easy to criticise the public speeches and announcements of UK Prime Minister Andrew Burnham. Apart from his lack of honesty, Burnham is irresponsibly facile in the things he says. Yet polls indicate that he is currently the most popular political leader. In his world, that counts as approval. He shrugs and moves on.

Monday, 2 November 2026

One Event, Two Narratives


The i Paper

Democrats rocked by despicable betrayal on eve of midterms vote

Democrat Congresswoman Haley Stevens of Michigan has stunned her party, two days before the midterm elections, by endorsing a Republican candidate in a seat critical to the fight for control of the Senate.



The Telegraph

'Despicable betrayal': Democrat endorses Republican rival

A Democrat congresswoman has caused dismay across the party by endorsing the Republican rival of Abdul El-Sayed, a hard-Left candidate, two days before the midterm elections.

The Duel


A duel as described in his posthumously published memoirs by Marcellin Marbot, a French cavalry officer and general who served during the Napoleonic Wars. The duel would have taken place before or shortly after he was born in 1782, possibly related to him when he was aide de camp to General Augereau, one of the duellists.


As a result of an absurd custom, there existed an inveterate hatred between some units, the cause for which was buried in the past and often hardly known, but which, handed down from age to age, resulted in duels every time the units met. In this way the Gendarmes of Luneville and the Carabiniers had been at war for half a century, though they had not seen one another in this long period of time.

At last, at the beginning of the reign of Louis XVI, they found themselves in the same camp at Compiegne; whereupon, to show themselves no less brave than their forefathers, the Carabiniers and the Gendarmes decided to fight, and their determination was such that the officers thought it wiser to look the other way. However, to avoid too much bloodshed, it was agreed that there would be only one duel; each unit would select a combatant who would represent them, and after that there would be a truce. The name of the combatant chosen by the Gendarmes would soon be known and after that it was merely a matter of arranging for the two adversaries to meet, when a simulated quarrel would serve as a motive for the encounter.

Augereau had a fearsome opponent, an excellent swordsman, a professional duelist, who as a warm-up, awaiting the contest, had killed two sergeants of the Guards, on the days previously. Augereau, without allowing himself to be intimidated by the reputation of this bravo, went to the cafe where he knew he was to appear, and while awaiting him sat down at a table. The Gendarme arrived, and when his opponent had been pointed out to him, he pulled aside his coat-tails, and sat down insolently on the table, his backside not a foot from Augereau's face.

Augereau was drinking a cup of very hot coffee at the time and he gently eased back the opening, called the ventouse, which existed then at the back of a cavalryman's leather breeches, and poured the steaming liquid onto the buttocks of the impudent Gendarme, who turned round in a fury! The quarrel having now been engaged upon, they went outside, followed by a crowd of Gendarmes and Carabiniers. As they went along, the ferocious Gendarme, to mock the man whom, he felt confident, would be his victim, asked Augereau, in a bantering tone, whether he would prefer to be buried in the town or in the country. "The country" replied Augereau, "I have always liked the open air." "Fine," said the gendarme, and, turning to his second, he said, "Put him with the other two I killed yesterday and the day before."

This was not very encouraging, and anyone but Augereau might have been put out, but determined to sell his life dearly, he defended himself with such skill that his adversary lost his temper and made a false move, which allowed Augereau, who had remained calm, to run him through, saying that it was he who would be buried in the country.


The Memoirs of General Baron de Marbot (1891)

Sunday, 1 November 2026

No mighty oaks from these little acorns grow



UK government wants Acorn carbon capture and storage project success – minister

The UK Government wants to see the Acorn carbon capture and storage project succeed, a UK minister has said, after concerns were raised about the way it is being funded.

The project in Aberdeenshire was due to receive £200 million in grant funding from the UK Government, but Chancellor John Healey changed the commitment to mean the UK Government would offer the same amount in loans or receive an equity stake in the project.

Scotland’s First Minister John Swinney has said he was “deeply concerned” about changes to the funding mechanism.

Acorn, which could support about 15,000 jobs at its peak, proposes storing emissions from across Scotland under the seabed of the North Sea.



Hence, too, might be drawn a weighty lesson from the little-regarded truth, that the act of the passing generation is the germ which may and must produce good or evil fruit in a far-distant time; that, together with the seed of the merely temporary crop, which mortals term expediency, they inevitably sow the acorns of a more enduring growth, which may darkly overshadow their posterity.

Nathaniel Hawthorne - The House of the Seven Gables (1851)

'It wasn't me' says Reeves



Brexit has made Britain poorer and weaker, Reeves says

Rachel Reeves has said she believes Britain should rejoin the European Union as she warned Brexit has made the country “poorer, weaker and less secure”.

The former chancellor voiced her support for Andy Burnham’s move to open the door to negotiations with Brussels as she said she “welcomed” his decision.

Writing in the Sunday Times, Ms Reeves said she accepted there was a “debate to be had” about the UK’s future in the EU, but that she believes the country’s future ultimately lies within the bloc.



Ousted political actors who performed as poorly as Reeves and in such a prominent role might gather back some shreds of dignity by leaving the stage completely.

Not something Rachel from Accounts wants apparently.