For argument based on knowledge implies instruction, and there are people whom one cannot instruct - Aristotle
Tuesday, 18 July 2023
What is it with Oxfam?
Len Shackleton has a worthwhile CAPX piece on the well-known decline of Oxfam.
Oxfam is up to its old anti-capitalist tricks again…
What is it with Oxfam?
This huge international charity, founded in 1942 as the Oxford Committee for Famine Relief to help the starving citizens of Nazi-occupied Greece, has over the decades done excellent work in the developing world, or what we must now call the Global South. But in recent years it seems to have lost its way.
There was the scandalous behaviour of its operatives in Haiti and Chad , and later in the Democratic Republic of Congo, and the inadequate way in which Oxfam reacted to reports of gross sexual misconduct, intimidation and bullying. This meant that the organisation has twice been temporarily banned from bidding for UK government aid funds , which constitute a significant chunk of its income.
There have been accusations that Oxfam has been consistently anti-Israel if not outright anti-Semitic, and in 2015 its Belgian affiliate was accused of indirectly funding Palestinian terrorism.
Well worth reading as yet another example of a once respected organisation which has declined, not into irrelevance, but into useful idiot status. The BBC is another example.
In March this year, the charity waded into the culture wars by publishing a 92-page document urging its staff to change words such as mother and father to the more inclusive ‘parent’, and expectant mothers ‘people who become pregnant’. A few weeks later, this standard-issue wokery was followed up by an extraordinary video post celebrating Pride Month, but appearing to depict JK Rowling as a hateful ‘Terf’.
Leaving all this stuff aside, a constant in Oxfam’s public personality for several years has been its taste for full-blooded attacks on the capitalist system, asserting that it’s a rip-off that immiserates the poor – a claim naturally accompanied by demands for massive political intervention and confiscatory levels of taxation.
And nothing will be done.
Labels:
decline
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
We were once sitting at a table outside a cafe in Oxford. A group sat down at the large table next to us, having just left Oxfam HQ. They were a bit noisy - they started out with florid sucking up to the bossman among them. Then they switched to a quite disgusting conversation that mocked all the volunteers who man their shops.
In a better ordered country I'd have machine-gunned the lot of them.
Let's face it, writing papers about the iniquities of capitalism is a lot easier than formulating a cogent case for fiscal reform, which in turn is far less stressy than working out distribution chains to the world's poorest people, which certainly beats the hard work of buying cheap food and arranging its transportation, which is an easier job than carrying heavy bags of milk-powder into villages and administering it to the starving.
As their sanitation experts might want to remind them, the shit tends to rise to the top.
A long time ago I used to support Oxfam. Famine relief seemed a worthy cause.
Oxfam changed to "Our vision is of a kinder, fairer world - a world less divided by borders, money, race or gender.” which doesn't actually mention famine relief. I guess the career apparatchiks have taken over. So I decided not to donate, not to volunteer, not to buy anything in their shops.
We gave up on all these faux 'cheridees' years ago, and this was confirmed after I saw a really incisive post about how they're strangling so many political organisations that don't comply with their usually left-wing ideals.
We do subscribe to The Air Ambulance though, as they're a normal crowd down this way!
dearieme - machine guns are the kindest way too.
Sam - yes it has taken an easier route to being noticed by the right people. Clearly it intends to have a prominent political profile - at least as prominent as its famine relief work.
DJ - the Charity Commission should have jumped on the drift into politics, but presumably it did nothing. As usual I suppose.
Scrobs - we only give to local charities although we donate to Air Ambulance via the collection bags they shove through the door.
Post a Comment