For argument based on knowledge implies instruction, and there are people whom one cannot instruct - Aristotle
Sunday, 11 July 2021
Government - the app we cannot delete
As we struggle to extricate ourselves from the coronavirus debacle here in the UK, it has become obvious that a number of features may be here to stay in one form or another. A rather hefty clue has been the NHS contact-tracing app, although the entire pandemic episode has been an even bigger clue to our likely future.
A government app which comes pre-installed on all communication devices is hardly a new idea, but was previously the stuff of dystopian science fiction or in a much more concrete form as the intentions of the Chinese Communist Party. It can be done technically, it can be placed on an acceptance spectrum from tolerated to necessary to positively virtuous. Anything beyond the spectrum doesn’t much matter.
A government app is only part of it though – a clue. Another clue is daily life, the life we actually lead in this modern world of ours, the comforts it offers, the routines it imposes, the background it allows us to forget, the restrictions it persuades us to ignore, the degeneracy it almost manages to hide.
An unmissable clue is how we slipped so easily into the coronavirus version of a police state. So easily that many seem not to have noticed and many more seem unconcerned. Some of us may deplore, hate or be outraged at what has happened to us, but it did not just happen, the pieces of the jigsaw were on the table to begin with.
Daily life itself has become very much like a government app we cannot delete and it is far from being a new situation. We are governed all the time, much of it in our heads, installed from the day we were born and updated every now and then. We are now on version 2021. Version 2022 comes next year. The coronavirus debacle was an update.
To a good approximation the pervasive reach of government is everywhere and this has been the case for many decades. Ever since it became possible via rapid communication. So much so, that it is impossible to catalogue the myriad influences government has on our lives . From the washing instruction label inside my shirt to the paint on the front gate to the design of the lamp post on the street – I effectively live within a government app and unless I’m horribly mistaken so do you.
When the NHS app evolves, it cannot possibly evolve in a direction which spells more freedom, less interference, less probing, less control. That wouldn’t make sense. Government functionaries make business for themselves. There is no freedom business.
Play the game or don’t play the game, it makes little difference because most will play it. It then becomes normal, accepted, the way things are done. Make an eccentric move or two – that about as far as the freedom game goes.
Labels:
government
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
I'm waiting for the first time that contact tracing or other covid related technology is used to solve a crime or to monitor terrorists. There's probably a clause that prevents this, but it's too tempting for them to leave it alone.
I have a lot of sympathy with this view, and supported 'No ID' as a protest about probable mission creep of compulsory ID cards. The place to avoid sliding down the greasy slope is at the top, not halfway down.
However we are one of the most densely populated countries, with an emphasis on high tech services rather than agriculture or industry. Everything *has* to work together or we will rapidly go hungry. You can still cherish your freedom in this country, but living off the grid is increasingly difficult and a great deal of hard work is required.
It's not comforting but we have to strike a balance.
The technology which 'recognises' citizens in the street will become the norm at some stage.
Presumably masking will have to be reduced as the triangulation techniques rely on the size of your nose etc., so is pretty useless at the moment!
Whatever happened to Google Glass?
Sam - I'm sure you are on the right lines. Supposedly it doesn't identify users, but believing that is quite a big step when the phone knows where you are anyway.
DJ - whatever balance we strike will certainly drift though. Where will it drift to? I don't know, but the drift towards some kind of totalitarian future seems the best bet so far. Could be benign, but we'd better find a way to ensure that.
Scrobs - yes I'm sure recognition technology will become the norm. I believe Google Glass is still around as a gadget used by some businesses. Worth looking up perhaps.
Post a Comment