Pages

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Labour's class war approach to business



Stephen Pollard
has a useful CAPX piece on Labour's failure to venture beyond its traditional class war approach to business. 


Labour’s mangled sixth-form-level Marxist class war

  • Labour MP Emma Reynolds told GB News she doesn't think employers are working people
  • It's clear that, even as a Treasury minister at the heart of economic policy, she holds 19th century Marxist views about employers
  • The misunderstanding of what business owners and landlords do, will discourage investors and lower available rental properties

Emma Reynolds, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, is one of the more sensible Labour MPs. She resigned as a front bencher when Jeremy Corbyn was elected leader and is firmly in the moderate wing of the Labour Party.

Which is why her comment yesterday that ‘I don’t think employers are working people’ is all the more revealing – and all the more telling about the attitude of the government. Plainly, my description of Reynolds as one of the more sensible Labour MPs is relative. When even someone as relatively sensible as Reynolds believes that employers are a class that don’t work for a living but somehow live off the backs of ‘working people’ then it shows the scale of Labour’s inability to grasp even the basics of wealth creation and growth – and thus the scale of the problem for our economy.


The whole piece is quite short and well worth reading as another reminder that Labour does not intend to base its voter appeal on an enlightened approach to small and medium-sized businesses.


Reynolds is no Marxist. But it’s damning of both her and Labour more generally that such a crude Marxist analysis of employers and employees drives their thinking, with no understanding of the nature of small and medium-sized businesses and how hard most employers work to create wealth and employment for their fellow working people. As one poster on social media put it: ‘It’s 7:41 on a Sunday, and I’m at my desk – guess I’m not a working person. My employees are not doing the same, I can tell you that (and I don’t expect or want them to!)’

7 comments:

dearieme said...

So Two-Tier's dad wasn't a worker after all.

A K Haart said...

dearieme - ha ha, by Labour standards he wasn't, Starmer should have been ashamed.

Macheath said...

With regard to the concept of employment, I wonder how female Labour MPs like Ms Reynolds (two children under 10, both born when she was a sitting MP) view their relationship with the nannies, childminders, cleaners etc who look after their children and homes while they work.

To me, the ideal of employing someone else - in all likelihood a low-paid woman* - to look after my house and infant children while I did a well-paid, high status job would be far more morally dubious (and counter to egalitarian principles) than taking on workers in a business sector; as a character in the TV series ‘Cracker’ memorably put it, “While you’re out lecturing about women’s rights and the glass ceiling, some poor cow’s got her arm halfway round your u-bend”.

* for an example, in 2009 it was reported that ‘Jacqui Smith’s cleaner at her 'second home' has been paid £2,400 a year - or about £46.15 a week - without a pay rise for five years. The national average wage has risen by 14.5% over this time.’

DiscoveredJoys said...

To the modern Labour mind there are *only* the oppressed and the oppressors. As a consequence employers, farmers, private schools, the 'far right' and the rich cannot have any redeeming features. Similarly Islamists, uncommon sexual orientations, illegal immigrants and 'the far left' cannot be blamed for their failings.

It's a break with reality because reality is difficult.

James Higham said...

And there's the future of productivity and growth in one.

A K Haart said...

Macheath - ah yes, the Jacqui Smith revelation. I agree, it is morally dubious behaviour when egalitarian principles are preached from a high status position. Jacqui Smith gave us all a lesson in political principles.

I suspect many MPs are socially adept, sometimes charming, but unpleasantly self-centred people who don't have a problem with preaching useless political nostrums to the masses as their escape route from the masses. It's probably plain enough to people who know them personally, such as their cleaners.

A K Haart said...

DJ - yes that's what always strikes me about the oppressed and oppressors approach to life - it's a simple way to set aside the difficulties of reality. It's so broad it's barely political, but the simplicity of it is very powerful indeed. It isn't even necessary to admit that it is the core principle, it can be used without that.

James - yes, dead or floundering, apart from nail bars etc.