For argument based on knowledge implies instruction, and there are people whom one cannot instruct - Aristotle
Tuesday, 21 May 2019
Anything short of terrorism
Quillette has an interesting review of a book by Terri Murray - Identity, Islam and the Twilight of Liberal Values.
Islamists in the West have successfully hijacked the moral prestige of liberal terminology for the purposes of disseminating ultra-social conservative beliefs and practices. Murray quotes the Pakistani-American writer Tashbih Sayyed, who pithily summarises the effects of this strategy as follows:
By casting its fascist agenda in terms of human rights and civil libertarian terms, political Islam has successfully been able to use the American liberal and progressive groups to project itself as an American phenomenon and win intellectual elites, liberals, and the media with left leanings on its side.
Murray correctly observes that violent acts of Islamic terrorism have had the effect of misleading people into thinking that anything short of terrorism is “moderate.” She points out that the ideology of an organisation may be extremist and deeply illiberal even if the group does not resort to violence to promote its views.
The whole piece is well worth reading. I particularly like this point - Murray correctly observes that violent acts of Islamic terrorism have had the effect of misleading people into thinking that anything short of terrorism is “moderate.”
Labels:
Islam
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Thanks, that is indeed an interesting review. The point about non-violent extremism is well made. It seemed to start with the Salman Rushdie case in the 1980s. Public book-burning was until then a figure of speech; something Nazis did in the 1930s. And now we have shouty intimidating pickets outside Birmingham primary schools. I don't remember much of that in my childhood.
The other good point made in the review is the issue of leftists thinking they could secularise and tame Islam. In fact, they were riding a tiger. So much damage done by immature unworldly dreamers.
Sam - yes the Salman Rushdie case should have been a much more powerful political warning than it was. Some of those immature unworldly dreamers walk the corridors of power too.
Post a Comment