Pages

Friday, 9 November 2012

The politics of nice



I’m no expert on American politics. I look on it from afar and I lack the personal touch one acquires from watching the interaction of political personalities. However, I do think that Obama’s election for a second term was predictable for two reasons:-

The polls seemed to lean slightly his way.
The political world is not pro-Romney – even in the US.

Yes there are important Democrat-leaning complexities such as the Latino vote, but it seems to me that for decades global politics has been shifting leftwards, but in a social as well as a political sense. It’s not so much a case of saying the right thing, but of not saying the wrong thing. So much is now either off-limits or difficult to express, so the easy route is to say nothing - nothing substantive at any rate.

So it's not so much a case of being the right type of person as not being the wrong type. We vote against people rather than for them.

Kingsley Amis wrote a comic novel called Stanley and the Women. Stanley's ex-wife Nowell reacts to people in only one of two ways. 

If they give in to Nowell's every whim, they are being nice. 
If they don't give in to Nowell's every whim, they are being nasty. 

Modern voters have a lot in common with Nowell. There is nothing even faintly sophisticated about voting and I'm not convinced there ever could be. 

Keep it crude - nice or nasty - that's the real political dichotomy. 

Sharp businessmen such as Romney are simply the wrong type. Of course many Americans don't see it that way, because it was a close election and Obama only just made it. Maybe the thing was also influenced by externals such as Sandy – maybe that very public whiff of executive concern was just enough to shift the balance. Who knows.

In the UK, the Conservative party has for years tried to divest itself of the nasty party image, the party where hard choices are presented and confronted. Increasingly people don’t want hard choices to be mentioned, let alone confronted. They want to hear about soft options, prefer muddling through, like to be organised and to organise others. 

Ours is becoming a strange domestic world, cut adrift from the past.

It’s been going on for decades, this rise in domesticity as a way of enfolding social, political and economic issues in a peculiar domestic embrace. 

The clues are everywhere, from the obsessive tidiness we euphemistically call recycling to the nice clean electric cars which might just as well have an Electrolux badge, because that’s what their proponents really want. Plus maybe a vacuum cleaner attachment to keep the roads clean.

Smoking is being stamped out because it’s seen as a nasty, dirty habit indulged in by dodgy people, those who don't conform. It's nothing to do with health - people don't give a rat's arse for your health, but they do want you to be clean and presentable in public. Nobody must be left out either, no cranks in the corner, no people who pop up to say nasty things they should have kept to themselves.

Alcohol is going the same way because nice people only ever drink in moderation and only ever in the evening. Even then it will be a nice wine rather than a stiff drink. You know what I mean too - unless you happen to be a thoroughly nice person.

Gifts are particularly nice. 

The political left goes very big indeed on gifts - particularly the delightful notions of choosing and receiving more than you give. The politics of gifting is a major feature of left-wing politics - helping yourself to the cake you didn't bake, lovely gifts slipped through as gold-plated pensions, sinecures, subsidies and grants. Year-round Christmas is what it's all about. As to the vexed question of how Santa fills his sack - well we are too nice to discuss that.    

We don’t like our powerful people to seem powerful and successful, but nicely spoken and considerate – inoffensive to a fault - one of us almost. If there are nasty decisions to be made then we don’t want to hear about it. Those things should be sorted out behind closed doors – nicely. Tea and biscuits helps.

Niceness is what it comes down to and the left does niceness very well. Desperately superficial it may be, but niceness is so often superficial because that’s a key part of being nice. 

Thinkers are not quite nice. They may be pleasant enough in their own way, but never nice, always tainted with that shadow of doubtful opinions, always prone to say something awkward, difficult or clever. Thinkers are conversation stoppers – we don’t want them round the dinner table.

Obama didn’t even have to portray himself as nice – which he isn’t of course. He merely had to present himself as nicer than Romney.

It’s how the left hoovers up votes and will continue to do so. Even in the US.

Thursday, 8 November 2012

Christmas gift idea


From PaulR

The Boundary


A bit speculative this.

What happens if we assume our ideas are limited by what we are as human beings? It isn’t an uncommon or improbable idea, yet what are we supposed to do with it? Usually we seem to do nothing with it – as if it isn’t relevant.

However, it seems to me that there was a time when human limitations were better recognised than they are now - we knew ourselves to be limited beings. Maybe we overdid it as times and maybe it was socially and politically useful to the elite, but we were aware of our fallibility.

Not that we don’t know it now of course, but we appear to have forgotten how to take at least some notice of it. To begin with, let’s give it a modern name – the Boundary. The Boundary is where our intellectual evolution ceased evolving. Our collective glass ceiling.

What is beyond the Boundary? A logical void – obviously. The Boundary has only one side because the other side is by definition unknowable. Yet modern rationalism has tended to forget the Boundary, carrying on as if all is knowable. To my mind, this came about when we accidentally decided or assumed that the universe is the sum total of what is real.

Yes, multiverse theories attempt to go beyond our universe, but the multiverse is scientifically ridiculous – it has no observable consequences. On the whole, we take the Boundary as encompassing the whole universe.

So the whole universe was brought inside the Boundary and the idea that all is knowable, at least in principle, seeped into the scientific mind. Or at least it seeped into those minds not paying enough attention to their own assumptions. Maybe it dates from Newton, but I don't think one can be quite that specific. It does have a Newtonian flavour though. The universe is mathematical and we can do maths - that kind of flavour.

Yet it seems to me that there are numerous clues to the possibility and even likelihood that the Boundary is lurking within the universe, not beyond it. In other words, we live with the unknowable and become familiar with it, but not to the extent of understanding it.

It’s the elephant in the room.

Take something familiar such as our economy. We know our economy is complex, but suppose it is more than complex – suppose it straddles the Boundary. In that case our economy would be partially understandable, but it would do strange things we could never explain. 

This problem would be an aspect of our limitations as evolved beings. It would not be resolvable by further study, new theories or better computer models. These efforts would not make any difference, because  in our models we cannot include phenomena which lie beyond the Boundary.

This of course is a Kantian idea – or at least one he developed. The unknowable phenomenon beyond our ken – the noumenon. 

To deal with the Boundary, we have to simplify wherever we can, because that may help us keep things on our side of the Boundary. It may not of course - we can't tell except insofar as our understanding seems to be incomplete.

We have to work within our limitations, without quite knowing what they are. For all we know, our whole civilisation depends on it – and that’s the point. The danger posed by the Boundary is that we don’t know where it is or what it hides from us.

It will cause problems we don't understand, events we did not foresee, consequences we didn't expect, events with unclear causes.

A little more humility might help, but our leaders are not strong on humility. This lack of official humility may be a far more serious weakness than they suppose. It certainly has been in the past...

Ah but I forgot - we no longer learn from the past.

Wednesday, 7 November 2012

Invaded by gadgets


Screenshot of Microsoft Windows 1.01
from Wikipedia

My life coincides quite closely with the development of microelectronics. From the invention of the transistor in 1948, to the Intel 4004 microprocessor in 1971, on to the Sinclair ZX81, the IBM PC, Windows and the modern tablet - I saw it all. Well most of it - I wasn't actually around in 1948. But I was fascinated by the possibilities as soon as Intel produced their 8080 microprocessor and the exciting notion of owning your own computer dawned.

I always expected home computers to evolve quite quickly into consumer products. In a way they have of course, but what I didn’t foresee in the early days was how much computing power would be gobbled up by our phenomenal hunger for graphics and graphical interfaces. I didn’t see how important the look of the thing would be, as opposed to what it actually does.

I thought word processing, spreadsheets and databases just about covered it as far as applications went. What more could anyone want?

Of course people wanted much more than that – and got it. Sometimes at the expense of computer performance which at one time seemed forever trying to catch up with hugely bloated software. Even so, the phenomenal advances in microelectronics have shrunk powerful computing devices down to the size of your hand – and smaller.

On Monday we were in PC World looking at the new KindleFire, comparing it to similar devices such as a Samsung Galaxy 7 inch tablet. The Kindle is an interesting device, not so much technically as functionally. It’s built to a mass market price with a view to tying the purchaser into Amazon's content such as books, films, music, news media and so on.

The Samsung on the other hand, is promoted as being more of a general purpose web access device, although with the free Kindle app, it can be much like a Kindle.

One thing I noticed with the Kindle Fire is the difference in price between two versions, with and without advertising - currently £129 with and £139 without. Amazon describes the difference as

Special offers and sponsored screensavers display on the Kindle Fire's lock screen.

Is this a sign of the future? For years computers have been bundled with all kinds of trial software, much of which is just a nuisance, but what of the future?

My ideal computer.
My ideal would look like a small mobile phone but thinner and lighter - about the size of a credit card. I'd communicate with it by voice only, with link back to my home computer and the Web. So I might be out walking and I'd ask it...

Any comments on my last blog post?
Three from the usual suspects. All of them rather witty so you'll be stuck for a decent reply.
Okay, take a photo of this antique pig trough and pop it into a draft post.
Done.
Any emails?
Only the usual Amazon crap.
Junk them.
Done. Am I supposed to be logging this walk via GPS?
Er - yes. Are you logging it?
Yes but you didn't tell me to.
Sorry.
That's okay. Nice pig trough.

Back home I'd have a very light 15/16 inch screen with a long battery life and wireless charging. For me, it is possible for computers to be too small. too fiddly with not enough information on the screen, so I see a decent screen as a necessity.

Not so sure about the keyboard.

I'm not sure about the mouse either, although in many ways it is the ideal pointing device. Touch screens are the thing of course. Apparently Windows 8 has been designed round touch, but for word processing and blogging I don't see the attraction.

That brings us to backup of important files and photos, which for me would be local - ultra simple wireless NAS. I can't see me ever trusting the cloud.

So for me, the computer doesn't have too far to go in order to become that consumer product I always expected. A few more twiddles and that's that as far as I'm concerned.

However...
Suppose computing devices evolve into bog-standard Web content portals and surfing as we know it today becomes more difficult – more clunky as you have to negotiate the built-in stuff which can’t be deleted because that’s what you signed up to when you bought your latest shiny gadget. Very much like the Kindle in fact.

It may well be that the Web ends up being policed via the devices we buy and their tied-in content providers. Not that the Web will become inaccessible, but the commercial content may be all most people see because that’s all they want out of the device. A gateway to the Web may still be open, but most people won't use it because all they want is glitzy content. Films, music, games, social froth and gossip from mainstream gossip mongers - maybe that's what the devices will focus on. As they tend to do now really.

So the big blogs will have to go mainstream to survive, signing up to content and advertising deals, simply in order to keep their audience. Other blogs will continue to be very much a minority interest.

Possibly not even that.

Tuesday, 6 November 2012

Toothache tip


From PaulR.

I'm pretty sure I remember this one from some research I did decades ago on early advertising. Presumably the drops worked quite well. 

Carbon capture capers



ClickGreen reports

The developers of Europe's leading capture capture [sic] and storage project have warned they are being forced to shut down operations after the UK Government refused to provide vital backing.

Do we know what vital backing may be? I think we do.

In July, the 650MW scheme in South Yorkshire topped the list of European CCS programmes competing for an estimated €337 million share of the €1.3 billion funding pot available in the EU's NER300 allowances.

The UK had four projects on the list but each required co-funding commitments from the UK. The pioneering Don Valley CCS project failed to win Government support despite working towards creating Europe's first industrial-scale carbon capture installation.

However, all is not lost – we still have four bidders.

But yesterday, DECC refused to support 2Co Energy, operators of the Don Valley CCS project, and selected four other bidders to be shortlisted for the next phase of its £1bn CCS comppetition. [sic].

Here is one of those four bids (my emphasis in bold).

Captain Clean Energy Project: A proposal for a new 570MW, fully abated coal Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (pre-combustion) project in Grangemouth, Scotland with storage in offshore depleted gas fields. Led by Summit Power, involving Petrofac (CO2 Deepstore), National Grid and Siemens

Carbon capture and storage (CCS) has always offered oil companies the tempting possibility of earning money from their depleted gas fields by using them for CO2 storage in these crazy CCS schemes. No wonder Big Oil is not necessarily opposed to climate games, nor particularly interested in pointing out how insane they are.